Honest conversations about holiday budgets and spending with family

The holidays are supposed to be a time of joy, but for many people, they’re loaded with stress, debt, and awkward conversations about money. With the pressure to buy gifts, travel, and keep up appearances, it’s easy to get caught up in traditions that leave us feeling overwhelmed and broke.

A friend of mine, another budgeter, told me how her mother always expected expensive gifts at Christmas. The siblings didn’t want to disappoint the mother, so the items were purchased and money was spent—just to meet expectations. On the other hand, I know some grandparents who love shopping at Shein, Temu, or the Dollar Store, thinking the more presents, the better. But they don’t realise how overstimulating it is for some kids to open exhaustive gifts, only to leave the house cluttered for months for the family.

That’s not exactly a relaxing way to enjoy the holidays.

Then there’s the expectation to travel, buy gifts for relatives we hardly see, and keep up the illusion of festive perfection. Much of what we do during the holidays is tied to the idea that it’s a “season of giving”—a phrase marketers have sold us. But for many people, it’s really a season of debt.

Instead of joy, it can feel like an endless source of stress.

If this sounds familiar, it might be time to have a difficult conversation with your family about adjusting expectations. Here are five ways to approach it with kindness and clarity.

  1. Start the conversation early | Bringing up the topic now gives everyone time to adjust. Saying, “This year, we’re planning to have a smaller Christmas,” well ahead of December will soften the surprise and set expectations early. It’s much easier to handle this conversation now than during the holiday rush when emotions run high.
  2. Suggest focusing on experiences | If your family tends to focus on physical gifts, try shifting the conversation to shared experiences. Let grandparents know that the kids might prefer something like “Grandma and Grandpa Camp” instead of toys that won’t last. A fun sleepover with baking, crafts, and stories could be far more meaningful than piles of presents—and it creates memories that last a lifetime.
  3. Offer thoughtful, homemade gifts | Personal, handmade gifts like cookie boxes or homemade vanilla essence can be a lovely alternative to store-bought presents. People who value the thought, effort, and time behind these gifts will appreciate them. They’re an affordable, heartfelt way to show love without adding to financial pressure. 
  4. Be upfront about financial limits | It’s okay to say no to things you can’t afford. If travel or big-ticket gifts aren’t in the budget, be honest about it. You could say something like, “We’d love to join, but that’s not in our budget this year,” or “We’re focusing on living within our means, so we’ll be keeping things simple this Christmas.” Being clear and calm sets boundaries without guilt.
  5. Consider alternative holiday traditions | One of the best ideas I’ve heard comes from a fellow budgeter whose family celebrates Christmas in July. They skip the stress of December altogether and instead enjoy a summer get-together with food, fun, and no presents. There’s no pressure, no scrambling to buy gifts—just sunshine and quality time. It’s a great reminder that the best part of the holidays is spending time with the people we care about.

 

The holidays aren’t supposed to be about an equal exchange of gifts. At their heart, they’re about connection, kindness, and joy.

There’s no need to rack up debt or exhaust yourself trying to meet expectations that don’t align with your values. When we shift the focus from stuff to experiences, we can create holiday traditions that are meaningful and manageable for everyone.

Starting these conversations now gives you and your family time to adjust and plan.

It’s okay to say no to things that feel like too much—whether it’s travel, expensive presents, or commitments to people you rarely see.

After all, the best gift you can give yourself is a holiday season that feels right for you.

This year, let’s slow down, make memories, and preserve our sanity and our budget.

Back to blog